A final decision on a proposed $1m penalty against a Nigerian doctor in Oakland has been postponed after city lawmakers failed to reach an agreement over allegations of unlawful tree felling.
Matthew Bernard, a US-based physician, is accused of removing about 38 protected trees without authorisation between 2021 and 2022, an action authorities say contravenes local environmental laws.
City officials disclosed that the trees were cut down on the couple’s property along Claremont Avenue in the Oakland Hills, with reports indicating that some of the affected trees were also located on adjoining plots and public land.
Environmental experts and advocacy groups have warned that the large-scale removal could have lasting ecological consequences, urging the council to impose stiff penalties to discourage similar violations.
Bernard, however, maintained during deliberations that the decision to remove the trees was based on expert advice suggesting potential wildfire risks. He insisted that he acted responsibly, although city authorities countered that no valid permit was secured.
The debate grew heated as council member Carroll Fife questioned the fairness of imposing the full penalty, raising concerns about possible racial implications in enforcement.
In contrast, fellow lawmaker Janani Ramachandran dismissed the argument, stressing that the issue was a straightforward violation of city regulations and should be treated as such.
Attempts to resolve the matter ended in a stalemate, with an initial vote on the $1m fine failing to secure a majority.
A follow-up proposal to reduce the sanction to $411,000 also ended without consensus.
With the council divided, the matter has been adjourned to May 5 for further deliberation and a possible final decision.
